“Pets Are Not Presents,” Critics Say as Celebrity Christmas Turns Controversial
Reality star Kim Kardashian is once again at the center of controversy — this time over a Christmas decision involving her children and several puppies. What was intended to be a festive family moment has quickly turned into a heated debate after animal rights organization PETA publicly criticized the move.
Kim reportedly gifted each of her children an individual puppy for Christmas, sharing the joyful moment online. While fans initially reacted with excitement, the narrative shifted almost immediately once animal welfare advocates weighed in.
Why PETA Is Calling It “Deeply Problematic”
PETA has strongly condemned the idea of giving animals as gifts, especially to children. Their argument centers on one core belief: pets are lifelong commitments, not holiday surprises.
According to critics, gifting puppies — particularly from breeders — reinforces the idea that animals are commodities. They argue this is especially damaging when done by global celebrities, whose actions often influence public behavior and trends.
The concern isn’t just about Kim’s family. It’s about the message being sent to millions of followers watching closely.
View this post on Instagram
Social Media Reacts: Cute or Careless?
As expected, the internet is divided.
Some fans insist Kim has the financial resources, space, and professional help to ensure the dogs are well cared for. Others aren’t convinced, pointing to past instances where Kardashian family pets seemed to quietly vanish from the public eye.
Critics argue that wealth doesn’t excuse the ethics of treating animals as presents — and that young children may not fully understand the responsibility that comes with pet ownership.
Celebrity Influence Under Fire
This incident has reignited a broader conversation about celebrity responsibility. When influential figures make personal choices public, those choices often become normalized.
Animal rights supporters say this is why Kim’s actions matter beyond her household. To them, this isn’t a personal attack — it’s a cultural critique of how animals are increasingly marketed as luxury lifestyle accessories.
Another Kardashian Backlash — Or a Valid Wake-Up Call?
Some believe PETA’s criticism is overly aggressive, accusing the organization of targeting Kim for attention. Others say discomfort is necessary to push meaningful conversations about adoption, breeding, and animal welfare into the mainstream.
Whether viewed as activism or exaggeration, one thing is clear: what began as a Christmas surprise has turned into a public ethics debate — and Kim Kardashian is right at the center of it.
